Q. She hated Texas history class. The Mexicans won the battle, killing all of the Texan soldiers inside the fort. The increasingly dictatorial policies, including the revocation of the Constitution of 1824 in early 1835, incited many federalists to revolt. “The Mexicans won the battle of the Alamo,” said the man, and the crowd laughed. While some sources state that he was killed during the battle, others indicate that he was one of the seven survivors executed on Santa Anna's orders. Yes, thats another part. Texas aged 18-29 are the least likely to know Mexico won the Battle of the Alamo (43 percent), and the most likely to think Texas won (31 percent), that the United States won 10 percent), and to say they don’t know at 17 percent, which I suppose is a way of answering the question correctly. But the fact of the matter is I’m an American, and I’m a Texan, and I view history through that, but I want to be honest about it because I think everybody has room at the table, and I want to be mature enough to say, yeah, I lost there, but guess what? “Why would we spend so much time talking about a loss? The Battle Of The Alamo 3666 Words | 15 Pages. Do most Latino / Hispanic-Americans view Islam positively or negatively? When Cynthia Orozco taught Texas history at the University of Texas at San Antonio, one of the first questions she would put to her students is who won the Alamo. William B. Travis, the commander of the Alamo sent forth couriers carrying pleas for help to communities in Texas. The Alamo is a story Texas has told to sort the good guys, who were the Anglo Texians, from the bad guys, or the Mexicans. While Travis and Bowie were killed in the fighting, Crockett's death is a subject of controversy. Cure taught seventh grade Texas history for eight years in Round Rock, a suburb just north of Austin. “No, this is true, but, but I’m gonna, I… I, you know, I…,” the senator began in the way of practiced public speakers do of throwing out a lot of rhetorical flares to buy himself some time. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. OPEN & UNLEASH THE LONE STAR STATE!!!”. Outnumbered, Houston began retreating … 1) The battle took much longer than he anticipated letting the Texan Army grow and train. He was a Texan in Mexico but a Mexican in Texas. For Texas independence. The Mexican border region of Texas was largely populated by immigrants from the United States. He has his back to the wall. Texas or Mexico who won? This seems to be kind of a curious proposition, almost a nonsensical proposition. Following his victory at the Alamo, Santa Anna moved quickly to destroy Houston's small Texas Army. 991 times. Mexico won the battle. Still have questions? “The American West was won at the Alamo AND the defeat of COVID19 must begin in Texas. It’s child’s play, literally, since state law mandates that every seventh-grader in Texas remember the Alamo. He checks with Congress. The famous siege of the Alamo in San Antonio lasted from February 23 to March 6, 1836. “Thinking back, I would say he was racist,” she said. The dramatic story of one of the most famous events in Texas history is told by Ben H. Procter. Battle of San Jacinto. The Battle of San Jacinto won independence for Texas. Mexico. Social Studies. The Texian resistance led by William B. Travis put up a brave stand but was ultimately crushed and all Texians involved in the battle were killed. 'The case is over': GOP senators check out at trial, 'Mandalorian' actress fired over 'abhorrent' posts, Sports power couple announces baby girl on way, Tax rule could mean bigger refunds for the savvy, 'I was suffering': Thicke on painkiller abuse, CDC updates quarantine advice for vaccinated people, Silver, NBA taking dreadful step in wrong direction, Strategists behind 'the Squad' launch progressive PAC, Storms march across U.S. with ice, snow and bitter cold, Krispy Kreme owned by ex-NBA star gutted by fire. 1 Green Bay Packers; 2 Betty White Birthday; The Texans lost the battle in The Alamo, but because of that battle they won the war. The myth of heroism and bravery is so pervasive that it clouds how Texans remember the Alamo. Procter describes in colorful detail the background, character, and motives of the prominent figures at the Alamo—Bowie, Travis, and Crockett—and the course and outcome of the battle itself. “They did lose the war, but they didn’t win that battle,” said the man at the back mic. Number of surviving defenders of the Alamo. Keren Lee Mr. Lewis AP US History 1 2 December 2014 The Battle of the Alamo The Battle of the Alamo was a devastating battle between the Texan and Mexican Army that occurred in the midst of the Texas Revolution and had an everlasting effect on the country and then state of Texas. “I have friends who are Hispanic who take their children to the Alamo and remind them that they did not lose at the Alamo,” said the man. On February 23, 1836, the arrival of General Antonio López de Santa Anna's army outside San Antonio.. Very logical reasons,” said Cure. Yes, that Phil Collins, but the focus here is on Menéndez, whose dad came from Cuba and mom from Mexico. I’m proud of my Cuban family. The people involved? This 14 words question was answered by Colleen R. on StudySoup on 5/31/2017. Who won the battle at the Alamo? What's a nice place to move to in Mexico? Found these on a hike in New Mexico recently. The battle over how to redevelop the Alamo and remember the site’s history has provoked death threats and emerged as a cause célèbre among Texas’s network of … How much has Mexico paid towards the wall so far? Even with Civil War battlefields, at least someone in the United States won. People go, ‘I’m a Texan.’ And, you know, me and my cousins got into a lot of arguments over this. My mom from Mexico, my dad from Cuba. This is why, Slotkin argues, we remember Pearl Harbor to justify entering World War II and not, for the sake of argument, Nazi aggression against our allies before December 7, 1941 or their documented atrocities toward Jews. To explore all newsletters, click here.By signing up, you agree to the terms of service and privacy policy. Perhaps the oddest bit of revisionism was when Missouri’s Todd Akin wrote a twisted vision of the Battle of the Alamo for the digital age: Mr. Speaker, we rise today to discuss this resolution that is in two parts before us. From Anglo and Hispanic students alike, she would always hear, “We won.”. “Why? The Mexicans won this battle big time. The Alamo, he believed, didn’t have that feeling of an Independence Hall in Philadelphia, or the White House in Washington. The Alamo was anything but: reviewers skewered it, John Wayne (its producer, director and major star), lost his shirt financing it, Hollywood ignored it... Related searches who won the battle … 2) There were also more casualties than one would expect from the Mexicans in this battle, thus weakening them before his defeat. The strategic objective of the stand was to delay Mexican forces and thereby permit military organization of the Texas settlers. One of the survivors was Susanna W. Dickinson and her infant daughter, Angelina. “Well, I don’t know what side you’re putting me on, but go ahead,” answered Menéndez. Mexico, but Santa Ana was defeated at San Jacinto. In Orozco’s college classes, “Basically, they would say that Mexico lost. White soon deleted his tweet, making orphans of the replies that contained jokes of varying wit. There just aren’t a lot of battlefields we preserve in the United States to remember the losers. I’m proud of my Mexican family. Sure, White got his facts backward. You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him think. On the eighth day of the siege, a band of 32 volunteers from Gonzales arrived, bringing the number of defenders to nearly two hundred. This confusion over who won and how this plays out in racial and ethnic identity caused an awkward encounter at a packed event at the Texas Tribune Festival in September 2016 on the campus of the University of Texas. “The Mexicans won the battle of the Alamo,” said the man, and the crowd laughed. Richard Slotkin, a professor at Wesleyan University, has a theory. “Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor?”, “Forget it,” says Boon. How do you say you support and then say, but we don’t want to send them any reinforcing troops? The battle scenes are well staged, but to modern viewers the racism is unsettling. White’s tweet was more like John Blutarsky’s exhortations to fraternity brothers. So he gets his BlackBerry out. And when George W. Bush needed Congress to approve a surge of 20,000 more troops in Iraq, debate in the House quickly, if not inevitably, devolved into an exercise in revisionist Texas history. The people who died in the World Trade Center, in the Pentagon, or on United Flight 93 were martyrs, and the only question was who we had to go kill to sanctify the dead. The Battle of San Jacinto won independence for Texas. This isn’t “kids today.” No one is getting off anyone’s lawn here. Things had gotten a little tense. The younger you are, the wronger you are, at least when it comes to the Alamo. Please reload the page and try again. Legacy of the Battle of the Alamo The Battle of the Alamo was a costly win for Santa Anna: he lost about 600 soldiers that day, to some 200 rebellious Texans. Most important reason The Alamo was so important. 30 seconds . The martyrdom at the Alamo justified, if not demanded, violent revenge, and something new was created, in this case, the Republic of Texas. “I’m interested to know why you said we didn’t lose. 102 Views. Trending Now. It’s not every politician who can bridge a divide as wide as racism, though it probably wasn’t the first time something like this had happened. (In fact, he did not mention the Alamo in public as president.). Who won the battle at the Alamo? Or can it be that the mysteries, … As we’ve mentioned, every single public school student in Texas gets a family-sized container of Alamo education. Bush, of course, got his troop surge. The second part says that we are not going to send them reinforcements. Getting this question wrong was consistent across our usual dividing lines, including sex, education, partisanship, and ideology. The Latest: ... who won the battle of the alamo mexico or texas: who won the battle of the alamo in 1836: 12 3. 66% average accuracy. On Texas Independence Day 2005 – March 2 for the uninitiated – Poe called Santa Anna the “19th-century Saddam Hussein.”. As the defenders saw it, the Alamo was the key to the defense of Texas, and they were ready to give their lives rather than surrender their position to General Santa Anna. My parents were immigrants. Where is the location of the Alamo? However, there was swift retaliation for that battle, and the Mexicans eventually lost the "war. February 23, 1836, began the siege of the Alamo, a 13-day moment in history that turned a ruined Spanish mission in the heart of downtown San Antonio, Texas, into a shrine known and revered the world over. This is why these myths – less the events themselves than the justification for further violence provided by martyrdom – have been used by presidents since Theodore Roosevelt to explain U.S. foreign policy. “Nobody wants to be the losers.”. Remembering whether the Japanese or the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor doesn’t matter as much as the reason for remembering in the first place: to exact revenge through restorative violence. How do you think about the answers? Lyndon Johnson cited the Alamo to urge support for the Vietnam War, which as a literal connection made little sense. Only as a myth of regenerative violence does that have any logic. Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), a packed event at the Texas Tribune Festival in September 2016, The financial press sounds alarms on San Antonio’s new EV charging contractor, A city can’t mourn numbers: Share remembrances of your loved one as we memorialize COVID victims, Hemisfair’s Civic Park going out to bid as a two-phase project, Proudly powered by Newspack by Automattic. He’s rolling.”. Instead, the Texas Twitterati ridiculed White for apparently not remembering that the Mexicans defeated the Texians at the Alamo. The question was asked, something along the lines of why didn’t the city preserve the Alamo intact as the city grew, and an answer was offered, which was something along the lines of because it just didn’t work out that way, and the man made a move to leave, not entirely satisfied nor surprised, before Collins spoke up with an impish tone. If this doesn’t seem funny, it’s because it wasn’t, and that’s not why they were laughing. The one who looked out of place was the slouching man at the end in the black polo shirt and black trousers. There’s a smallness to it, which Menéndez chalked up to a major city growing up around it. Save. And I tell my children the same thing. … What would happen if Mexico tried to take back new mexico by force? But the answer goes deeper than emphasis to what the battle represents these days in our popular imagination. Gettysburg, at least for most Americans, is remembered as a pivotal victory. That’s a 12-year-old’s logic. Texas’ Ted Poe probably remembered the Alamo more than anyone in Congress and seemed to love nothing more than to link the Alamo to the war on terrorism. That’s what Stephen Cure thinks. Getting his facts exactly straight about Texas’ creation myth doesn’t essentially matter to White as much as the truthiness of his all-caps appeal to the governor to unleash the Texas economy to defeat COVID-19 with the full force of our commerce. Whether we ended up with victory or death remains an open question, and I in no way am arguing that Bush used the Alamo to sell the troop surge or in fact any part of the war on terrorism. Answer. When it comes to the Alamo, who we are is a loaded question in Texas, where Hispanics are as likely to know Mexico won the Battle of the Alamo as they are to think Texas did. The Battle of The Alamo took place in 1836 between February 23 and March 6 in present-day San Antonio, Texas. Upload Date: 5/31/2017. Republic of Texas. “I think at the time I would say I felt like, yeah, I’m with the heroes of the Alamo or with the victors,” she said. No matter where you go in the world and you start talking, ‘Hey, where you from?’ if it’s a Texan the first thing they say is, ‘I’m a Texan.’ Have you noticed that? Others could have grown resentful. Jason Stanford co-wrote, with Bryan Burrough and Chris Tomlinson, Forget the Alamo: The Rise and Fall of the American Myth, due out June 2021 from Penguin Books. In the centuries before the battle, the Alamo had served as a Catholic mission, working to convert local Native Americans to Catholicism. After the first Battle of the Alamo in 1835, in which Anglos and Tejanos defeated Mexican General Martín Perfecto de Cos's forces inside the Alamo compound, the push for … wurstercats. And I am going to argue that it’s precisely because Texas culture places so much emphasis on the Alamo that confusion now exists among younger folks. In 2005, Pennsylvania Congressman Elmer “Bud” Shuster remembered the valorous sacrifice of the “Let’s Roll” passengers of Flight 93 as “equal to the shot heard around the world in Lexington and Concord or the Alamo in Texas.” Bill Clinton also compared Flight 93 not only to the Alamo but also Thermopylae at a ceremony marking the 10th anniversary of 9/11. “In the schools, basically the way we grew up is that the Alamo, what we learned from that as Mexican Americans is that Texas won and Mexico lost. If this doesn’t seem funny, it’s because it wasn’t, and that’s not why they were laughing. Following a 13-day siege, Mexican troops under President General Antonio López de Santa Anna launched an assault on the Alamo Mission near San Antonio de Béxar (modern-day San Antonio, Texas, United States), killing all of the Texian defenders. Santa Anna has got thousands of troops. Whoops! The Mexicans won the battle, but Texas ultimately won its independence from Mexico. Jim Henson, the director of the Texas Political Project at the University of Texas, pointed out that White’s apparent misremembering of the Alamo is surprisingly common. So going to a big theater, it’s like a treat, right? So we are saying, oh, we want support, but we don’t want to support you. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Who are you referring to?” he asked. “We never even left our neighborhoods. Over 200 defenders were killed in the battle of the Alamo. They’d come for one of the great oddities in Texas history, Phil Collins, who amassed reputedly the largest collection of Alamo memorabilia in the world and then donated it to the state of Texas. As the battle climaxed with a massive attack over the walls, the defenders… Read More The Battle of the Alamo was won by the Mexican Army The Mexicans won this battle big time. It took place at a fort in San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo. Every year, he always put on his final exam who won the Battle of the Alamo. When al Qaeda terrorists attacked the United States, remembering the Alamo became inevitably intertwined with never forgetting 9/11. And it’s why Sam Houston’s troops yelled “Remember the Alamo!” at the Battle of San Jacinto and not some appeal to independence or self-determination. The Battle of the Alamo gave the force under the direction of Sam Houston at San Jacinto time to prepare and fortify. But his tweet had what Stephen Colbert used to call “truthiness,” an emotional standard for accuracy in which what is felt to be true by the teller is right. Commentary: Mixing up the winners and losers at the Alamo is shockingly common for reasons that, once you look into it, make a … You are now signed up to receive The Curve, sent each weekday evening. “I remember hating that class because it was boring and he didn’t make it relevant to us.”, Hernandez, now a Chicana activist, does have fond memories of the school trip to the Alamo and the IMAX, where the Alamo movie has been a field-trip staple for area kids since the late ‘80s. Her teacher, an older man, stuck to the John Wayne version of history in which Anglos were the good guys and Mexicans and Indians were bad. But what is it that makes this one battle so different from any other battle fought in the name of freedom? In 1831, Mexican authorities lent the settlers of Gonzales a small cannon to help protect them from frequent Comanche raids. “The Mexicans won that battle,” said Menéndez, who paused, trying to draw the man into the light. James White, a state representative who went to Houston public schools, undoubtedly took Texas history as a schoolboy before getting his doctorate and teaching Texas history himself.
Arcoaire Furnace Codes, Dacquoise Recipe Julia Child, Akg K712 Pro, Hashtags For Punjabi Wedding, Cat C12 Performance Upgrades, One Bedroom Rock Hill, Sc, Where To Buy Cuisine Adventures French Onion Soup, A Woman's Worth Quotes,